Three questions with three purposes
First decide what information is missing. Choose whose to identify the owner. Choose which when speakers can see or have already mentioned several alternatives. Use how with an appropriate adjective when you need a measure of a property.
Context determines the choice. Whose, which and how are not interchangeable: they guide the listener towards different kinds of answers.
possession → whose; limited choice → which; degree or measurement → how + adjective
- adjective —
- A word describing what someone or something is like: happy, tired, interesting.
Whose keys are these?
Whose keys are these?
The question asks who owns the keys, so use whose.
Which bus do we need, 4 or 7?
Which bus do we need, 4 or 7?
Two options are named, so which signals a limited choice.
How far is the station?
How far is the station?
The question asks for a distance, so use how far.
Whose: asking about possession
Whose asks who something belongs to. It can come before a noun: whose coat, whose phone, whose books. The noun immediately identifies the item being asked about.
Whose can also stand alone when the item is visible or already mentioned: Whose is this? Whose are these? A natural answer names the owner or uses a possessive pronoun: It’s Amir’s; They’re ours.
Do not confuse whose with who’s. Who’s contracts who is or who has, while whose asks about possession.
Whose + noun + …? / Whose + be + this / that / these / those?
- noun —
- A word naming a person, thing or idea: student, book, happiness.
Whose jacket is this?
Whose jacket is this?
Whose comes before the noun jacket.
Whose is this jacket?
Whose is this jacket?
Whose stands alone; the item is named later in the sentence.
Whose are these gloves?
Whose are these gloves?
Plural gloves agrees with are.
Which: choosing from known options
Which asks for a choice from a limited set. The options can be named in the question, displayed on a menu or board, or already understood from the conversation.
Which can come before a noun: Which train? Which colour? It can also stand alone when the items are clear: Which is yours? Which do you prefer?
What more often opens a general set of answers that has not been limited in advance. What colour do you like? is not ungrammatical; it simply does not restrict the choice to two colours. In a real situation, both what and which may be possible if the speaker frames the set differently.
Which + noun + …? / Which + auxiliary or be + …?
- noun —
- A word naming a person, thing or idea: student, book, happiness.
- auxiliary —
- A helping verb used to form tenses, questions or negatives: do, have, be.
Which T-shirt do you want, the blue one or the green one?
Which T-shirt do you want, the blue one or the green one?
The two named alternatives form a limited set.
Which is your seat, 12A or 12B?
Which is your seat, 12A or 12B?
Which stands alone, while seat is named after be.
What music do you like?
What music do you like?
No fixed list is supplied, so open-ended what is more natural. This is a contrast in meaning, not the correction of an error.
How + adjective: degree or measurement
How before an adjective asks about degree or requests a measurement. Particularly useful common A1 combinations are how old for age, how tall for height, how far for distance, how long for duration or length, and how big for size.
The adjective determines the kind of answer. How old calls for an age, how far for a distance, and how long for a duration or length depending on the object and context.
Not every combination of how with an adjective is equally common. Learn frequent combinations first, and check whether the expected answer really measures that property.
How + old / tall / far / long / big + question structure?
How old is your dog?
How old is your dog?
How old asks for an age.
How tall is the shelf?
How tall is the shelf?
How tall asks about vertical size.
How long does the lesson last?
How long does the lesson last?
How long asks about duration in this context.
How big is the room?
How big is the room?
How big asks for a description or measurement of overall size.
Word order depends on the rest of the question
There is no single universal formula for all these questions. With be, place it before the subject: How old is Mia? Which is yours? With other verbs in Present Simple, do or does is often needed: Which bus do we need? How long does the film last?
Whose or which plus a noun can itself be the subject. In that case, do not add do: Whose phone is ringing? Which bus goes to the airport? Identify the phrase’s role before inserting an auxiliary.
Use a question mark in a direct question. Indirect-question word order is a separate topic and is not practised here.
with be: question phrase + be + subject?; with another verb in an object or adverbial question: question phrase + do / does + subject + base verb?
- subject / S —
- The grammatical subject: who or what the clause is about; the verb agrees with it. In The book was written, the book is the subject, although someone else does the action.
- verb / V —
- A word for an action or state, such as work or be. The pattern determines its form.
- V1 / base form —
- The base verb without to: work, go, be.
- object / O —
- Who or what an action affects: in I read a book, a book is the object.
How far is the hotel from here?
How far is the hotel from here?
Is comes before the subject the hotel.
Which folder do you need?
Which folder do you need?
This direct object question with need requires do.
Which train goes to York?
Which train goes to York?
Which train is the subject, so does is not needed before goes.
A short answer must match the question
Whose expects an owner: Sara’s, mine, theirs. Which expects a selection: the small one, bus 7, this one. How + adjective expects the relevant measure: twelve years old, about two kilometres, forty minutes.
Conversation does not always require a full sentence, but the answer must be sufficient and clear. In a written exercise, follow any explicit requirement about the number of sentences or turns.
Whose notebook is this? — It’s Dana’s.
Whose notebook is this? — It’s Dana’s.
The answer identifies the owner.
Which mug do you want? — The large one.
Which mug do you want? — The large one.
The answer selects one object from the known set.
How far is the bank? — About one kilometre.
How far is the bank? — About one kilometre.
The answer gives a distance.
Scope and using the questions in conversation
This lesson does not practise how much or how many for quantity, or how much for prices. They have separate rules. Relative whose and which in subordinate clauses are also outside the scope.
To use the skill in conversation, imagine the expected answer. An owner’s name points to whose, one of several options to which, and a measurement of a property to how + the appropriate adjective.
When a task asks for your own example, you may use real or invented facts. Preserve any facts supplied in the prompt. Check an open response for meaning, the target form, word order and naturalness. The model is not the only acceptable wording.
Whose is the black umbrella?
Whose is the black umbrella?
The item is visible, and the question asks about its owner.
Which time is better for you, nine or ten?
Which time is better for you, nine or ten?
The listener chooses between two named times.
How long is the break?
How long is the break?
The expected answer is a duration.
Common mistakes
Incorrect:Who bag is this?
Correct:Whose bag is this?
Use whose, not who, before bag to ask about its owner.
Incorrect:Whose phone this is?
Correct:Whose phone is this?
In this direct question with be, is precedes the subject this.
Incorrect:Which you want, the blue one or the green one?
Correct:Which do you want, the blue one or the green one?
With want in this Present Simple object question, place the auxiliary do before you.
Incorrect:How old your sister is?
Correct:How old is your sister?
In the direct question, place is before the subject your sister.
Incorrect:How long does the lesson lasts?
Correct:How long does the lesson last?
After does, the main verb takes the base form last without -s.
Incorrect:How far is to the station?
Correct:How far is it to the station?
This distance construction needs the subject it.