VocairoStart learning

Try doing or try to do: experiment or effort

Both patterns are grammatical, but they present an action from different perspectives: try + -ing presents it as a method or experiment, while try + to-infinitive presents an attempt to achieve a difficult goal.

Published

Two questions about the same action

After try, the form of the next verb helps show what we mean by trying. If the question is Will this method work?, try + -ing is natural. If the question is Can I manage this difficult action?, use try + to-infinitive.

This is not a correct-versus-incorrect pair. The same action can appear in either pattern, but the speaker changes the focus. The problem, goal, difficulty, and expected result in context therefore determine the choice.

How to build it

try + verb-ing = test a method; try + to + base verb = attempt to perform an action

verb / V
—
A word for an action or state, such as work or be. The pattern determines its form.
V1 / base form
—
The base verb without to: work, go, be.
V-ing / -ing
—
The verb form ending in -ing: working, going. Its role depends on the construction.

Try restarting the router.

Try restarting the router.

Restarting is proposed as a possible solution to the problem.

I tried to restart the router, but the button was stuck.

I tried to restart the router, but the button was stuck.

The focus is on the effort to perform a difficult action.

Try + -ing: test a method

Try + verb-ing means perform an action as an experiment and see whether it helps, is enjoyable, or produces the desired effect. It is common in advice about technology, work, learning, healthy habits, and everyday problems.

When referring to the past, this pattern usually indicates that the method was actually tested. Its result can be positive or negative, however: tried opening the window does not mean the room became cooler.

How to build it

try + opening / changing / using / not using

Have you tried moving the desk nearer the window?

Have you tried moving the desk nearer the window?

Moving the desk is considered as a way to get more light.

We tried working in the library, but it was still too noisy.

We tried working in the library, but it was still too noisy.

The method was tested, but it did not produce the desired result.

Try + to-infinitive: make an effort

Try + to + base verb expresses an attempt to do or achieve something. The context often provides an obstacle: the action is difficult, time is short, something is broken, or the result does not depend on the speaker alone.

Try to do does not itself say whether the attempt succeeded. The continuation clarifies the result: I tried to call her, and eventually she answered or I tried to call her, but there was no signal.

How to build it

try + to + open / reach / finish / avoid

She tried to lift the suitcase, but it was too heavy.

She tried to lift the suitcase, but it was too heavy.

The weight creates an obstacle to performing the action.

I will try to finish the report before lunch.

I will try to finish the report before lunch.

The speaker commits to making an effort; success is not yet known.

The form after try

After try meaning experiment, use an -ing form without to: try changing, tried taking, have tried using. After try meaning attempt, use to and the base form: try to change, tried to take, is trying to use.

Tense and aspect are expressed on try: tried, is trying, have tried. The following form remains verb-ing or to + base verb. These patterns do not use a bare infinitive after try: try open and tried fix are ungrammatical.

How to build it

try / tried / be trying + verb-ing or to + base verb

verb / V
—
A word for an action or state, such as work or be. The pattern determines its form.
V1 / base form
—
The base verb without to: work, go, be.
V-ing / -ing
—
The verb form ending in -ing: working, going. Its role depends on the construction.

Mina is trying to finish the report.

Mina is trying to finish the report.

The continuous form is expressed in trying; to finish remains after it.

They have tried using a shared calendar.

They have tried using a shared calendar.

Have tried forms the Present Perfect; the method being tested takes the form using.

Negatives: what not to do

A negative before the second action preserves the meaning contrast. Try not to interrupt means make an effort to avoid interrupting. Try not using notifications for a day means test a day without notifications and observe the result.

Do not confuse these forms with negating try itself. I did not try to call means no attempt to call was made; I tried not to call means the speaker made an effort to avoid calling.

How to build it

try not to + verb = make an effort to avoid an action; try not + verb-ing = test the absence of an action

verb / V
—
A word for an action or state, such as work or be. The pattern determines its form.
V-ing / -ing
—
The verb form ending in -ing: working, going. Its role depends on the construction.

Try not using your phone after nine and see whether you sleep better.

Try not using your phone after nine and see whether you sleep better.

Avoiding the phone is an experimental change of habit.

I tried not to wake the baby, but the floor creaked.

I tried not to wake the baby, but the floor creaked.

The speaker made an effort to avoid an unwanted action.

When both options are possible

A real situation can contain both a method and a difficulty. Try opening the window presents opening it as a possible solution to a stuffy room. Try to open the window presents opening itself as an action that may be difficult. Both can be appropriate if the context supports the intended focus.

Words such as but, difficult, or see if often offer clues, but they are not automatic markers. Read the whole meaning: but can introduce either an experiment's unsuccessful outcome or an obstacle to an attempted action.

How to build it

the same verb ≠ the same message

verb / V
—
A word for an action or state, such as work or be. The pattern determines its form.

I tried opening the windows, but the room was still stuffy.

I tried opening the windows, but the room was still stuffy.

The windows were opened as a way to ventilate the room; the method did not produce the desired result.

I tried to open the windows, but the handles would not move.

I tried to open the windows, but the handles would not move.

An obstacle prevented the action itself from being completed.

Using the contrast in advice and narratives

In advice, identify the problem first, then propose an action as a test: Try lowering the brightness; it may save battery. In an account of a difficult goal, state the effort and result: I tried to finish before five, but I needed another hour.

To express the contrast in natural language, combine the patterns: We tried using a checklist, and I will try to follow it every day. The first part names a tool that was tested; the second describes a personal effort to follow it.

How to build it

problem → try + -ing as a method; difficult goal → try + to-infinitive as an effort

V-ing / -ing
—
The verb form ending in -ing: working, going. Its role depends on the construction.
infinitive
—
The base verb form. With to: to work; without to: work. The pattern determines whether to is needed.

Try taking a short break; you may return with a clearer idea.

Try taking a short break; you may return with a clearer idea.

The speaker proposes testing one way to solve a problem.

I tried to stay calm during the interview.

I tried to stay calm during the interview.

Staying calm was a goal requiring effort.

Common mistakes

Incorrect:Try restart the router; it may solve the problem.

Correct:Try restarting the router; it may solve the problem.

Do not put a bare base form after try in this pattern. The proposed experiment requires an -ing form.

Incorrect:I tried opened the jar, but the lid was stuck.

Correct:I tried to open the jar, but the lid was stuck.

The attempt pattern needs to followed by the base form open, not the past form opened.

Incorrect:She is try to finish the report.

Correct:She is trying to finish the report.

After is in the Present Continuous, use trying.

Incorrect:We tried to working in the library to see if it was quieter.

Correct:We tried working in the library to see if it was quieter.

Do not combine to with an -ing form here. Working in the library was tested as a method.

Incorrect:He tried not wake the baby, but the floor creaked.

Correct:He tried not to wake the baby, but the floor creaked.

In the effort pattern, retain to + base verb after not.

Sources
Practise with Vocairo