VocairoStart learning

Would have been doing: an ongoing action in another scenario

C1 · Imagine different circumstances and look back at an activity that would have been ongoing under them. Would have been + -ing presents a process, not automatically a completed result. Establish the reference point, duration, and relationship to the condition from context.

Published

1. A view inside an imagined process, not a factual report

Imagine that a rehearsal was cancelled. We know its schedule and assume that, without the cancellation, the participants would have followed it. Would have been rehearsing lets us describe an ongoing action in another scenario, not an actual rehearsal.

A typical use is imagined activity in the past: what would have been happening then, or would already have been continuing for some time. The condition explains the different circumstances under which it would have been possible; the result is viewed from within, as an activity.

How to build it

If + subject + had + V3, subject + would have been + -ing verb

subject / S
—
The grammatical subject: who or what the clause is about; the verb agrees with it. In The book was written, the book is the subject, although someone else does the action.
verb / V
—
A word for an action or state, such as work or be. The pattern determines its form.
V3 / past participle
—
The third verb form: worked, gone, seen. Used after have/has or in the passive, for example; it is not always the same as V2.
V-ing / -ing
—
The verb form ending in -ing: working, going. Its role depends on the construction.

If the rehearsal hadn't been cancelled, we would have been practising at eight last night.

If the rehearsal hadn't been cancelled, we would have been practising at eight last night.

Under the stated schedule, eight o'clock falls within the imagined rehearsal; we do not assert that it took place.

If we had started at six, we would have been practising for two hours by eight.

If we had started at six, we would have been practising for two hours by eight.

This adds retrospective measurement: from the imagined start at six to the reference point of eight.

2. Build the verb sequence and change only the necessary part

Would is followed by have, not has or had. Next come been and an -ing form: would have been waiting. The sequence is the same with I, she, they, and other subjects.

The negative is would not have been waiting or wouldn't have been waiting. In a question, would moves before the subject: Would she have been waiting? For duration, ask How long would she have been waiting?

I'd have been working means I would have been working; I'd worked means I had worked. Would’ve is also standard: I would've been working. In standard writing, use have or ’ve, not of.

How to build it

subject + would (not) have been + -ing; question: Would + subject + have been + -ing?

subject / S
—
The grammatical subject: who or what the clause is about; the verb agrees with it. In The book was written, the book is the subject, although someone else does the action.
V-ing / -ing
—
The verb form ending in -ing: working, going. Its role depends on the construction.

With an earlier delivery, she wouldn't have been waiting outside all morning.

With an earlier delivery, she wouldn't have been waiting outside all morning.

The imagined extended wait is negated; not belongs with would, while have been remains unchanged.

How long would you have been driving by the first stop?

How long would you have been driving by the first stop?

Would precedes you; keep have been driving in order rather than swapping been and have.

I'd have been writing all evening if the meeting had ended earlier.

I'd have been writing all evening if the meeting had ended earlier.

Here ’d means would: have already follows the contraction and begins the perfect sequence.

3. The reference point: then, up to now, or up to a future boundary

Perfect looks back from a reference point; the name of the form does not replace the time context. We most often discuss the past here, but imagined duration can extend to now or to a specified future boundary.

For marks a duration, since a starting point, and by the boundary from which we look back: for two hours, since nine, by eleven. Hours measure the activity, not the number of finished products.

With by now or by next June, make the retrospective perspective explicit: when the process would have begun and how long it would have continued by that point. The future example below describes a life scenario that has already failed to materialise, not a prediction of what will actually happen.

If I had joined the team in January, I would have been working there for eight months by now.

If I had joined the team in January, I would have been working there for eight months by now.

The context places us at the end of August. The duration is measured up to the present reference point, not only to a completed past date.

If we hadn't moved away, we would have been living there for ten years by next June.

If we hadn't moved away, we would have been living there for ten years by next June.

We have already left; we imagine continuing to live there and look back from a future ten-year boundary. This is not a promise to return.

4. A process implies neither a completed result nor an interruption

Would have been repairing emphasises repair as an activity. Would have repaired three chairs presents three repaired chairs as a result. For three hours does not tell us how many chairs would have been finished.

However, Simple does not always mean a single completed action: would have managed the team for a year can describe a whole period of management. Would have been managing highlights its ongoing nature. Do not declare grammatical Simple incorrect merely because it offers another perspective.

Continuous alone does not prove that the work was interrupted or never finished. Such conclusions require additional facts. The activity can also be repeated: evening classes, rather than a class continuing without any break.

Would be working now naturally presents an imagined process now. Would have been working for four hours by now additionally looks back at its duration up to the present. Both forms are possible; the communicative purpose determines the perspective needed.

With the spare tools, I would have been repairing chairs all morning; I can't say how many I would have finished.

With the spare tools, I would have been repairing chairs all morning; I can't say how many I would have finished.

The imagined activity does not guarantee a particular number of results; the second clause explicitly limits the conclusion.

If she had stayed, she would have managed the team for another year.

If she had stayed, she would have managed the team for another year.

This is a grammatical sentence about a period spent in a role, not necessarily a completed one-off action.

If I had kept that job, I would have been teaching evening classes every week.

If I had kept that job, I would have been teaching evening classes every week.

This concerns regular activity in an unrealised scenario, not one endless class.

5. The condition is not limited to one if-formula

For a specific changed past event, If + Past Perfect is the usual condition. However, the condition's form depends on its own time: in a mixed conditional, a general unreal characteristic can take If + Past Simple or were while the result concerns past activity.

The condition may be understood from the previous turn or expressed through without or otherwise. What matters is that the listener can recover which circumstance we are changing.

Two facts alone do not prove a conditional relationship. “Lesia resigned” and “someone else is now in charge” do not guarantee that Lesia would have been promoted. Such a scenario needs an explicit assumption about the appointment and continuation in the role.

If I lived nearer the office, I wouldn't have been travelling for two hours before yesterday's meeting.

If I lived nearer the office, I wouldn't have been travelling for two hours before yesterday's meeting.

We assume a different permanent home location; the imagined result concerns the duration of yesterday's journey. Past Perfect is not obligatory in the condition.

The outdoor workshop was cancelled. Otherwise, we would have been drawing in the park all afternoon.

The outdoor workshop was cancelled. Otherwise, we would have been drawing in the park all afternoon.

Otherwise refers to the workshop not having been cancelled; its schedule included drawing in the afternoon.

Assuming the promised promotion had gone ahead, Lesia would have been managing the department for a year by now.

Assuming the promised promotion had gone ahead, Lesia would have been managing the department for a year by now.

The speaker openly supplies an assumption rather than presenting the result as a deduction from resignation alone.

6. Preserve the actor, modality, and verb meaning

Would have been interviewing means that the actor would have been conducting interviews. Would have been interviewed is passive: someone would have interviewed that person. Been without a following -ing form does not by itself mean Continuous.

In this lesson, would presents a result within an accepted hypothesis. Might have been doing expresses possibility and is not a mechanical synonym. When translating, do not replace a hypothetical result with merely a possible hypothetical result.

States such as know in its ordinary knowledge meaning do not normally take Continuous: use would have known. If you need a process of acquiring knowledge, choose a genuine activity such as would have been studying, but remember that this changes the meaning.

If I had accepted the recruiter role, I would have been interviewing applicants all morning.

If I had accepted the recruiter role, I would have been interviewing applicants all morning.

I names the person asking the questions; replacing interviewing with interviewed changes that person's role.

If you had told me, I would have known the reason.

If you had told me, I would have known the reason.

Known appropriately expresses the state of knowing. Adding been knowing does not improve the answer merely because the lesson concerns Continuous.

7. Using the construction in your own response

First establish the alternative scenario, then the reference point, and then decide what matters most: the activity itself, its duration, or a completed result. Only then build the verb sequence.

In a coherent response, you do not need to put every verb in the same form. Real events, an imagined process, and limits on the conclusion serve different functions. Models in open-ended exercises are guides for checking your work, not the only permitted wording.

I chose the later shift. If I had taken the early one, I would have been serving customers for four hours by noon. That doesn't tell us how many orders I would have completed.

I chose the later shift. If I had taken the early one, I would have been serving customers for four hours by noon. That doesn't tell us how many orders I would have completed.

The actual choice, imagined working period, and limitation on the conclusion are kept distinct; the context assumes that the early shift began at eight.

Common mistakes

Incorrect:She would has been waiting outside.

Correct:She would have been waiting outside.

After modal would, use the base form have, regardless of the subject she.

Incorrect:We would have be working all morning.

Correct:We would have been working all morning.

After have in this sequence, use the past participle of be: been.

Incorrect:They would have been wait for us.

Correct:They would have been waiting for us.

To express an ongoing action after would have been, use an -ing form, not the base form wait.

Incorrect:Would she been have driving then?

Correct:Would she have been driving then?

In a question, move would before the subject but preserve the order have been.

Sources
Practise with Vocairo