Shifting Tenses in Reported Speech
Reporting the Meaning, Not Rearranging Every Word
In a reported statement, name the speaker and convey the meaning of their statement. After said, you can use that or leave it out. Quotation marks around the report are not needed. A report tells us what was said; this does not by itself confirm that the statement is true.
Backshift is a change in tense when we view a statement from a past point in time. It does not move the event itself to another day.
speaker + said (that) + subject + verb
- subject / S —
- The grammatical subject: who or what the clause is about; the verb agrees with it. In The book was written, the book is the subject, although someone else does the action.
- verb / V —
- A word for an action or state, such as work or be. The pattern determines its form.
Rita said that she was busy.
Rita said that she was busy.
Her original I'm busy described her state during the conversation; was conveys that state from a past point in time.
I said I needed a break.
I said I needed a break.
I am reporting my own words, so I remains I; need changes to needed.
Present Forms from a Past Perspective
When we apply backshift: Present Simple changes to Past Simple, Present Continuous to Past Continuous, and Present Perfect to Past Perfect. Preserve the difference between a habit, an ongoing process, and an action that has already been completed.
work → worked; am/is/are working → was/were working; have/has worked → had worked
Oleh said he checked the stock every morning.
Oleh said that he checked the stock every morning.
The original I check described a habit, so the simple form checked is needed.
Nadia said she was checking the stock.
Nadia said that she was checking the stock.
Her I am checking described a process that was happening at that time.
Sam said he had checked the stock.
Sam said that he had checked the stock.
His I have checked reported a stock check completed before the conversation.
An Action Before an Earlier Conversation
We often report Past Simple as had + V3, and Past Continuous as had been + -ing. This shows that the event happened before the speaker's words.
In natural reporting, Past Simple or Past Continuous is sometimes retained when the time relationships are clear. In exercises requiring complete backshift, we practise Past Perfect specifically; another grammatical option may not meet the exercise's goal.
Mila said she had lost the key on Monday.
Mila said that she had lost the key on Monday.
The original I lost the key on Monday is reported with clear backshift: lost → had lost.
Dan said he had been cooking at six.
Dan said that he had been cooking at six.
The original I was cooking at six became had been cooking; six o'clock did not change.
Do Not Add Endless had Forms
Do not backshift the Past Perfect again: had finished remains had finished. Present Perfect Continuous becomes had been working with backshift. Do not add a second had to an auxiliary verb that is already complete.
Eva said she had already eaten before the call.
Eva said that she had already eaten before the call.
Her I had already eaten before the call already contained the Past Perfect, so the form stayed the same.
Leo said he had been waiting for an hour.
Leo said that he had been waiting for an hour.
The original I have been waiting for an hour relates the duration to the conversation; after backshift, we have had been waiting.
Modal Verbs: Form and Meaning
With backshift, will usually becomes would, can becomes could, and may in the sense of possibility becomes might. The base form of the verb remains after them.
Could, would, should, and might are usually kept. Do not turn every piece of advice or possibility into a completed action by adding an unnecessary have + V3.
will send → would send; cannot open → could not open; may rain → might rain
The courier said he would call.
The courier said he would call.
Would expresses an action that was future relative to his words; it does not yet prove that the call happened.
Zoe said she could not open the file.
Zoe said she could not open the file.
The original I can't open the file retains the negative meaning.
Ben said we should take a map.
Ben said we should take a map.
The original We should take a map remains advice with should.
When You Can Keep the Current Form
Backshift is not always required after said. If a fact is still true, the result is still relevant, or a promised event is still in the future, you can keep the present form or will.
A backshifted tense by itself does not prove that a fact is no longer true. With says, there is no automatic requirement to change to the past tense when reporting a current state.
Tara said she works at the library. She still works there.
Tara said she works at the library. She still works there.
Works directly connects the report with a current fact; worked can also be appropriate in the report.
The driver said he will arrive at seven. It is only six.
The driver said he will arrive at seven. It is only six.
The future event has not happened yet; will is acceptable, as is the backshifted version would.
Marta says she needs the address.
Marta says she needs the address.
Says reports a current statement, and needs preserves the current need.
Who Is Speaking, When, and Where
Change I, we, you, and the words today, here, and tomorrow according to the actual reporting situation. If you are reporting your own words, I can remain I. If it is the same day, you can keep today: changing it to that day is not automatic and depends on the narrative perspective you choose.
First identify the speaker, the listener, and the time of the event. Then choose the tense. This helps preserve the meaning even in a short statement.
On Wednesday, I explained that Nina had said she would arrive on Tuesday.
On Wednesday, I explained that Nina had said she would arrive on Tuesday.
On Monday, Nina said I will arrive tomorrow. The stated date Tuesday removes dependence on the day of reporting.
We said we were ready.
We said we were ready.
We are reporting our own We are ready; are changes, but the participants do not.
Common mistakes
Incorrect:She said she had wrote the note.
Correct:She said she had written the note.
After had, use the third form written, not the Past Simple wrote.
Incorrect:He said he would arrived at eight.
Correct:He said he would arrive at eight.
After would, use the base form arrive; the past perspective has already been expressed by the modal verb.
Incorrect:They said they was waiting.
Correct:They said they were waiting.
With they, use were; backshift does not cancel subject–verb agreement.
Incorrect:I said I didn't knew the answer.
Correct:I said I didn't know the answer.
After didn't, use the base form know.
Incorrect:He said he had had finished.
Correct:He said he had finished.
In had finished, the auxiliary had is already present. A second had is unnecessary here; this is not the construction had had + noun, for example had had lunch.