Advanced existential and presentational constructions with there
There introduces new information
In an existential construction, there does not indicate a place. It fills the grammatical subject position, while the noun phrase after the verb names what exists, appears, remains, or happens. The speaker first opens a position for new information, then names it.
The postverbal phrase is most often indefinite: a discrepancy, several options, no evidence. This is natural because the construction usually introduces a participant into the discourse. However, it is a strong tendency, not a ban on every definite phrase: There remains the question of cost can present a specific question as an unresolved item.
Compare A discrepancy remains and There remains a discrepancy. Both are grammatical; the first makes discrepancy the topic from the outset, while the second presents it as new information or an important result of a review.
there + finite verb + noun phrase + additional information about place, time, etc.
- verb / V —
- A word for an action or state, such as work or be. The pattern determines its form.
- NP / noun phrase —
- A noun phrase: a noun with its dependent words, such as the new student; the pattern treats it as one group of words.
- noun —
- A word naming a person, thing or idea: student, book, happiness.
There remain two unresolved questions about the sample.
There remain two unresolved questions about the sample.
Two unresolved questions is new information after remain. In formal writing, plural questions requires remain.
There remains the question of long-term funding.
There remains the question of long-term funding.
The question names a specific unresolved item. A definite phrase is natural here, although other contexts more often introduce something not yet mentioned.
Verbs beyond be: register varies
Be is the most frequent verb, but there also occurs with intransitive verbs of existence, persistence, appearance, and occurrence. Exist and remain are particularly useful in formal exposition; arise, emerge, and occur introduce a problem, pattern, or event; there followed has a distinct narrative or literary tone.
Replacing there is with another verb does not automatically make writing academic. Choose the precise meaning and appropriate tone: there exists states existence, there remains identifies what is left, and there followed often organizes a narrative sequence.
Not every verb fits this construction. Ordinary transitive verbs such as discuss, own, or solve cannot simply follow dummy there. You need a suitable verb of existence, appearance, persistence, or event sequence.
there + appropriate form of exist / remain / arise / occur / emerge / follow + noun phrase
- NP / noun phrase —
- A noun phrase: a noun with its dependent words, such as the new student; the pattern treats it as one group of words.
- noun —
- A word naming a person, thing or idea: student, book, happiness.
There exists a simpler explanation for the result.
There exists a simpler explanation for the result.
Exists asserts the existence of one explanation in a formal style.
There arose an unexpected dispute during the hearing.
There arose an unexpected dispute during the hearing.
Arose introduces a new past event and is natural in an official or narrative account.
There followed a silence that lasted several minutes.
There followed a silence that lasted several minutes.
Followed organizes the narrative sequence; it is not a neutral replacement for there was in every genre.
Seem and appear: an apparent existence
There seems to be and there appears to be are typical ways to express a tentative conclusion. In formal writing, seem or appear agrees in number: There seems to be one error, but There seem to be two errors.
To have been places the supposed event earlier: There seems to have been a misunderstanding. The speaker now assesses a probable past misunderstanding rather than asserting it without qualification.
In It appears that the figures are incomplete, dummy it precedes a full that-clause. In There appear to be missing figures, the verb phrase is followed by the missing figures themselves. Both patterns are correct, but do not mix them. Separately, appear can mean come into view, allowing There appeared a figure without to be.
there + seem(s) / appear(s) + to be / to have been + noun phrase
- NP / noun phrase —
- A noun phrase: a noun with its dependent words, such as the new student; the pattern treats it as one group of words.
- noun —
- A word naming a person, thing or idea: student, book, happiness.
There appears to be a mismatch between the totals.
There appears to be a mismatch between the totals.
Appears softens the conclusion, while a mismatch supplies the new information.
There seem to be two missing pages in the appendix.
There seem to be two missing pages in the appendix.
In formal writing, seem agrees with plural two missing pages.
There seems to have been a misunderstanding about the deadline.
There seems to have been a misunderstanding about the deadline.
To have been locates the possible misunderstanding before the present assessment.
Agreement: formal norms and variation in usage
In formal writing, the verb normally agrees with the number of the following noun phrase: There exists one exception, but There exist several exceptions; There remains one concern, but There remain several concerns. This is a reliable pattern for an examination, report, or article.
There's before a plural is very common in informal speech: There's two messages for you. For formal writing or an examination, choose There are two messages for you. Recognize the conversational variant without automatically transferring it to formal writing.
In lists, agreement with the first item is possible: There is a printer and two scanners in the room. For clearer formal writing, you can put the plural first: There are two scanners and a printer in the room. This is an option for such a list, not a general rule for all noun combinations.
There exist three independent reasons to repeat the test.
There exist three independent reasons to repeat the test.
Plural three independent reasons requires exist in formal writing.
There’s two people waiting outside.
There’s two people waiting outside.
A common informal conversational version; choose There are two people for formal writing.
There is a printer and two scanners in the equipment room.
There is a printer and two scanners in the equipment room.
Is agrees with the first item, a printer. Reversing the order naturally gives There are two scanners and a printer.
Tense, modality, and perfect forms
An auxiliary or modal before be conveys time, possibility, necessity, or other meanings: There will be, There may be, There must be, There has been. There remains in the dummy subject position.
In a perfect form, the auxiliary also agrees in number: There has been one change, but There have been several changes. A lexical verb can likewise take different tenses: There arose a problem, There remains a problem, where the verb and style fit.
Different modal negatives have different meanings. There may not be enough time allows the possibility of insufficient time; There need not be a delay says a delay is unnecessary; There cannot be a simple answer denies the possibility of a simple answer.
there + modal verb + (not) + be + noun phrase; perfect: there + has/have + (not) + been + noun phrase
- verb / V —
- A word for an action or state, such as work or be. The pattern determines its form.
- NP / noun phrase —
- A noun phrase: a noun with its dependent words, such as the new student; the pattern treats it as one group of words.
- noun —
- A word naming a person, thing or idea: student, book, happiness.
- modal —
- A modal verb expresses meanings such as ability, possibility or necessity: can, may, must.
There may be another explanation for the anomaly.
There may be another explanation for the anomaly.
May expresses possibility, not a fact or permission.
There have been several revisions since May.
There have been several revisions since May.
Have agrees with several revisions and forms the Present Perfect.
There need not be a conflict between the two aims.
There need not be a conflict between the two aims.
Need not denies the necessity of a conflict, not its actual existence.
There to be and there being
There can serve as the dummy subject of an infinitive clause. After want, expect, and need, and in the for pattern, there to be is possible: We expect there to be enough time; For there to be a fair comparison, both groups need the same test.
After a preposition, use being: They objected to there being only one reviewer; The chance of there being an error is small. The whole construction determines whether to be or being is required.
There having been several complaints, the policy was reviewed is possible, but is a rare formal construction with its own subject, there. In ordinary writing, Because there had been several complaints, the policy was reviewed is often clearer.
verb allowing an infinitive + there to be …; preposition + there being …
- verb / V —
- A word for an action or state, such as work or be. The pattern determines its form.
- infinitive —
- The base verb form. With to: to work; without to: work. The pattern determines whether to is needed.
- preposition —
- A word showing a relationship, such as in, on or from: from Ukraine.
We expect there to be enough seats for every participant.
We expect there to be enough seats for every participant.
Expect permits the infinitive clause there to be, with there as its dummy subject.
They objected to there being only one reviewer.
They objected to there being only one reviewer.
To in object to is a preposition, so it requires being after it.
For there to be a fair comparison, both samples must be tested alike.
For there to be a fair comparison, both samples must be tested alike.
For introduces an infinitive clause with its own dummy subject, there.
Negatives, questions, and question tags
In questions, the auxiliary precedes there: Is there likely to be a delay?; Have there been any objections? With lexical remain or exist in the Present Simple, use do/does: Do there remain any alternatives? Often, Are there any alternatives left? is more natural.
Put negation on the auxiliary or within the noun phrase: There does not appear to be an error; There appears to be no error. These are often close in meaning, but the first denies apparent evidence of an error, while the second presents the impression that no error exists.
In a question tag, repeat there as the subject: There has been a misunderstanding, hasn't there? Tense and negation follow ordinary question-tag rules. Hasn't it? would incorrectly replace there with it.
Are there likely to be further delays?
Are there likely to be further delays?
Are precedes there and agrees with plural delays.
There does not appear to be enough evidence yet.
There does not appear to be enough evidence yet.
Negation of appear is formed with does not; the assessment of the evidence remains tentative.
There has been a misunderstanding, hasn’t there?
There has been a misunderstanding, hasn’t there?
The tag repeats the auxiliary has and dummy subject there.
Boundaries: place, it, have, and inversion
Locative there indicates a place and can be stressed: There it is; Put the folder there. In There arose a problem, unstressed there does not name a place. There is a problem there contains both meanings: the first there is a dummy subject, and the second indicates a location.
There goes the bus points to an event the speaker is currently perceiving, while On the shelf stood a vase begins a description with a location. These are related but separate patterns. This lesson mainly uses there to introduce existence or an event.
Dummy it can anticipate a full subordinate clause: It appears that the totals differ; It is surprising that no one objected. Possessive have requires a subject identifying the possessor: The report has two appendices. To state the appendices' presence, use There are two appendices in the report, not There has two appendices.
There it is, beside the blue folder.
There it is, beside the blue folder.
There indicates a place; the pronoun it precedes is.
It appears that the totals were copied incorrectly.
It appears that the totals were copied incorrectly.
Dummy it anticipates the that-clause; this differs from there followed by a noun phrase after the verb.
The report has two appendices.
The report has two appendices.
The report identifies the document with appendices. There are two appendices in the report states the same fact by starting with their presence.
Common mistakes
Incorrect:There remains several unresolved questions.
Correct:There remain several unresolved questions.
In formal writing, plural several unresolved questions requires remain.
Incorrect:There exists two plausible explanations.
Correct:There exist two plausible explanations.
In formal writing, plural two plausible explanations requires exist.
Incorrect:There seems be a discrepancy in the totals.
Correct:There seems to be a discrepancy in the totals.
After seems in this meaning, use the infinitive to be.
Incorrect:We expect there be enough time for questions.
Correct:We expect there to be enough time for questions.
After expect, this infinitive clause takes the form there to be.
Incorrect:They objected to there be only one reviewer.
Correct:They objected to there being only one reviewer.
To in object to is a preposition; use there being after it.
Incorrect:There may not exists a simple solution.
Correct:There may not exist a simple solution.
After modal may, use the base form exist without -s.
Incorrect:There discussed several alternatives at the meeting.
Correct:Several alternatives were discussed at the meeting.
Discuss is transitive and cannot directly follow dummy there. Passive were discussed reports the discussion without inventing who conducted it.
Incorrect:There has two appendices in the report.
Correct:There are two appendices in the report.
Possessive has does not form this existential construction; plural appendices requires there are.
Incorrect:There has been a misunderstanding, hasn't it?
Correct:There has been a misunderstanding, hasn't there?
Repeat dummy there in the tag rather than replacing it with it.
Sources
- Cambridge Dictionary Grammar — There is, there’s and there are
- Cambridge Dictionary Grammar — Seem
- Cambridge Dictionary Grammar — Appear
- Cambridge Dictionary Grammar — Here and there
- Cambridge Dictionary Grammar — It
- Hiltunen and Tyrkkö — Existential there constructions in early medical texts
- Krejci and Hilton — There’s three variants: agreement variation in existential there constructions
- University of Massachusetts Amherst LINGUIST 601 — Infinitival Complementation
- Cambridge Dictionary examples — remain