Both … and: both one and the other
What both means
Both refers to two people or two things TOGETHER, as one pair. It does not express a choice between two (that choice is expressed by either), and it does not express a negative statement about both at the same time (that is expressed by neither).
Both by itself says nothing about feelings or evaluation—it only indicates that the statement concerns exactly two things or people taken together.
Both my brothers live in Kyiv.
Both my brothers live in Kyiv.
Both states a fact about the two brothers together, not about just one of them.
I've read both books this month.
I've read both books this month.
Both books means the two books as a pair, not a choice of one of them.
Both explanations make sense to me.
Both explanations make sense to me.
Unlike “either explanation makes sense” (any one of the two explanations makes sense), here BOTH explanations make sense.
Both + noun without of
When a bare plural noun follows both—with no the, this, my, or another determiner—of is not used at all.
Both + plural noun (without a determiner, without of)
- noun —
- A word naming a person, thing or idea: student, book, happiness.
- determiner —
- A word before a noun that helps identify it: a, the, my, this, some.
Both cats sleep most of the day.
Both cats sleep most of the day.
Cats is a bare plural noun, so use simply both, without of.
Both restaurants serve good coffee.
Both restaurants serve good coffee.
Restaurants also appears without a determiner—the form is the same.
Both children go to the same school.
Both children go to the same school.
Children is a plural noun without a determiner; of would be incorrect here.
Both (of) + determiner or possessive
When a determiner (the, these, those) or a possessive determiner (my, his, our...) comes before a specific noun after both, of may be included or omitted—the meaning does not change.
Both (of) + the/these/those/my/his/... + noun
- noun —
- A word naming a person, thing or idea: student, book, happiness.
Both my sisters study medicine.
Both my sisters study medicine.
Both comes before the possessive my without of—this is the form without the preposition.
Both of my sisters study medicine.
Both of my sisters study medicine.
The meaning and the subject are the same; only of has been added—both versions are correct.
Both of those restaurants are closed on Mondays.
Both of those restaurants are closed on Mondays.
Those is a demonstrative determiner, and of is also optional here: “both those restaurants” is also possible.
Both of + pronoun; both after the subject
Before an object pronoun (them, us, you), of is required: you cannot say “both them” or “both us.”
After a subject pronoun, both is used without of: they both, we both, you both; them both is also possible as an object. Both refers to two people or things, so I both without a second participant does not mean “we both.” With be, the usual order is They are both ready; with an auxiliary, it is They have both arrived.
Both of + them/us/you | subject pronoun + both
- subject / S —
- The grammatical subject: who or what the clause is about; the verb agrees with it. In The book was written, the book is the subject, although someone else does the action.
- pronoun —
- A word used instead of naming a person or thing: I, you, she, it, they.
Both of them work at the same hospital.
Both of them work at the same hospital.
Them is an object pronoun, so of is required.
They both work at the same hospital.
They both work at the same hospital.
The meaning is the same, but both comes after the subject they, and of is omitted.
I invited both of you to the meeting.
I invited both of you to the meeting.
You is also an object pronoun here, so of is needed.
Both ... and: joining two elements
Both ... and joins exactly two elements in one statement: both comes immediately before the first element, and comes before the second.
The simplest combinations use parallel parts: two nouns, two adjectives, or two verb phrases. Each part must fit the shared part of the sentence: is both affordable and comfortable.
both + element A + and + element B (A and B have the same form)
Both my brother and my sister live abroad.
Both my brother and my sister live abroad.
Both joins two subjects (two possessive noun phrases) into one compound subject.
The hotel is both affordable and comfortable.
The hotel is both affordable and comfortable.
Both elements are adjectives with the same form.
He both fixed the shelf and painted the door.
He both fixed the shelf and painted the door.
Both elements are verb phrases with the same subject, he.
When the subject refers to two, use the plural
If both or both … and forms the subject and refers to two participants, the verb must be plural: Both are ready; Both Ana and Leo are ready. If both … and joins adjectives or actions of one subject, that subject determines the number: The hotel is both affordable and comfortable.
both / both of + plural group → are / were / work; both A and B as two subjects → plural
Both the manager and the assistant are attending the meeting.
Both the manager and the assistant are attending the meeting.
Each subject is singular on its own, but the compound subject both ... and always takes a plural verb: are.
Both of the windows were open all night.
Both of the windows were open all night.
Both of + a plural noun takes a plural verb too.
Both students are ready.
Both students are ready.
A bare plural noun with both again takes a plural verb.
Boundaries: both / either / neither
Both refers to the two together, either refers to any one of the two, and neither refers to not one of the two. Before a noun, the forms are different: both answers, but either answer and neither answer. With of: both/either/neither of the answers.
Both can emphasize different parts of a phrase: in both Rome and Florence joins the city names, while both in Rome and in Florence joins two groups beginning with in. Both versions are grammatical; choose the one that clearly expresses the intended relationship.
Both answers are acceptable here.
Both answers are acceptable here.
Both = a fact about both answers together.
Either answer is acceptable here.
Either answer is acceptable here.
Either = a choice of one of the two, not both at once.
Neither answer is acceptable here.
Neither answer is acceptable here.
Neither = a negative statement about both answers at the same time—this is a different rule in this topic.
Common mistakes
Incorrect:Both of students are ready for the exam.
Correct:Both students are ready for the exam.
Of is not placed directly before a bare plural noun without a determiner; students appears without the/my, etc., so of is unnecessary.
Incorrect:Both them love spicy food.
Correct:Both of them love spicy food.
Before the object pronoun them, of is required: both cannot stand directly before the pronoun without it.
Incorrect:Both the manager and the intern is coming to the training.
Correct:Both the manager and the intern are coming to the training.
Both ... and always gives the compound subject a plural verb, even when each subject is singular on its own.
Incorrect:Both my colleague or my manager approved the request.
Correct:Both my colleague and my manager approved the request.
Both is used only with the conjunction and; or is confused here with the structure either ... or.
Incorrect:He enjoys both cooking or gardening.
Correct:He enjoys both cooking and gardening.
In the pair both … and, the second conjunction must be and. Cooking and gardening are two -ing forms after enjoys.