Concession and contrast markers
Concession as a two-step argument
A concession does not mean abandoning your position. The writer first acknowledges a fact, limitation or the strength of another argument, then shows why the main conclusion still stands. This movement — “I acknowledge X → despite X, I maintain Y” — makes an argument more precise and persuasive.
Ordinary contrast simply compares two different facts. A sentence with whereas does not necessarily imply that one fact is an obstacle to the other. Before choosing a marker, decide whether you are conceding a point or simply comparing two sides.
A marker does not create logic by itself. The two parts must form a real contrast: if the second statement merely repeats or explains the first, a different connection is needed.
acknowledged point X → concession or contrast marker → main conclusion Y
Admittedly, the sample is small, but the pattern is consistent.
Admittedly, the sample is small, but the pattern is consistent.
Admittedly openly acknowledges a weakness; but returns to the argument the writer maintains.
The urban sites expanded, whereas the rural sites remained stable.
The urban sites expanded, whereas the rural sites remained stable.
Whereas compares two outcomes; neither is presented as an obstacle to overcome.
Three grammatical frames
Admittedly and parenthetical Granted can comment on a whole statement: Admittedly, X, but Y; Granted, X, but Y. A comma separates the comment. The return to the main claim is often explicit, although it can also be clear from the wider context.
Granted is also a conjunction in Granted (that) + subject + predicate. Here, a comma need not immediately follow Granted: it closes the entire concessive clause before the main clause. Granted that the estimate is rough, it remains useful is therefore correctly structured.
Notwithstanding is a formal word meaning “despite”. As a preposition, it comes before or after a noun phrase: Notwithstanding the delay; the delay notwithstanding. The formal conjunction pattern notwithstanding (that) + full clause also exists. Do not therefore restrict all its uses to nouns.
Admittedly, statement, but main claim | Granted (that) + full clause, main claim | Notwithstanding + noun phrase, main claim
- NP / noun phrase —
- A noun phrase: a noun with its dependent words, such as the new student; the pattern treats it as one group of words.
- noun —
- A word naming a person, thing or idea: student, book, happiness.
- clause —
- A construction with a verb, often with its own subject: when I arrived. A non-finite clause may leave the subject unspoken: to get home.
Granted that the forecast is uncertain, we still need a working budget.
Granted that the forecast is uncertain, we still need a working budget.
That introduces a full concessive clause; the comma follows uncertain, not Granted.
Notwithstanding the delay, the review was completed before publication.
Notwithstanding the delay, the review was completed before publication.
Notwithstanding is followed by the noun phrase the delay, without of.
The delay notwithstanding, the review was completed before publication.
The delay notwithstanding, the review was completed before publication.
Postposition is more formal and particularly typical of concise written accounts.
Admittedly and Granted: the writer concedes a point
Admittedly signals “I acknowledge that this is true or that it is a weakness”. It often sounds like an open evaluation by the writer and works well before but, yet or a separate following sentence.
Granted presents a statement as an accepted premise for the next argument. Parenthetical Granted often acknowledges a point briefly; Granted that makes the syntactic connection with a whole clause explicit.
These markers are not interchangeable with therefore: they do not derive a consequence but acknowledge information that could weaken the following conclusion.
Admittedly, the first estimate was crude, but it guided the initial decision.
Admittedly, the first estimate was crude, but it guided the initial decision.
The writer acknowledges a flaw in the estimate without denying its practical usefulness.
Granted, the proposed timetable is demanding; nevertheless, it is achievable.
Granted, the proposed timetable is demanding; nevertheless, it is achievable.
Granted acknowledges the objection, while nevertheless after the semicolon introduces the conclusion that is maintained.
That said and Be that as it may: turning from the preceding statement
That said or Having said that refers to the idea just expressed and immediately limits its force. It is a natural way to introduce a reservation in professional and general writing, and is less ceremonious than Be that as it may.
Be that as it may is a fixed formal expression. The speaker allows that the preceding statement may be true but explicitly shows that it does not change the decision, obligation or main conclusion.
Both expressions need actual preceding content to refer to. If the reader cannot identify what that means, the transition will be unclear.
The interface is faster than before. That said, several accessibility issues remain.
The interface is faster than before. That said, several accessibility issues remain.
That said qualifies the positive evaluation by adding an important limitation.
The evidence may be disputed. Be that as it may, the statutory deadline still applies.
The evidence may be disputed. Be that as it may, the statutory deadline still applies.
The formal expression acknowledges the dispute but does not allow it to change the procedural conclusion.
Nevertheless and notwithstanding: similar meaning, different syntax
Nevertheless and nonetheless are linking adverbs: they mean that the following statement remains true despite the obstacle just mentioned. At the start of a new sentence, they are normally followed by a comma.
If nevertheless links two independent clauses in one sentence, a comma alone before it is not enough. A semicolon or full stop is needed before the marker: X; nevertheless, Y. A comma alone creates a comma splice.
Nevertheless usually links complete statements as an adverb. Notwithstanding often introduces the name of an obstacle — notwithstanding the delay — and can follow it. In formal style it can also be a conjunction before a full clause.
independent clause; nevertheless, independent clause | Notwithstanding + named obstacle, main clause
- clause —
- A construction with a verb, often with its own subject: when I arrived. A non-finite clause may leave the subject unspoken: to get home.
The pilot was costly; nevertheless, it exposed a critical flaw.
The pilot was costly; nevertheless, it exposed a critical flaw.
Both clauses are independent, so nevertheless is preceded by a semicolon and followed by a comma.
Notwithstanding repeated objections, the committee approved the revised protocol.
Notwithstanding repeated objections, the committee approved the revised protocol.
Repeated objections is a noun phrase naming the obstacle.
Concession or simple comparison?
Whereas and contrastive while compare two characteristics, groups or trends. They are useful when the writer does not want to present the first clause as a concession: X has one property, whereas Y has another.
Although, even though and much as introduce a subordinate concessive clause, but their syntax differs from that of framing adverbs. In the standard construction, do not add but to an although-clause: Although X, Y, not Although X, but Y.
Do not pile up markers without a purpose. Granted ... but ... or X; nevertheless, Y may be enough. Granted ... but nevertheless ... is sometimes possible for strong rhetorical emphasis, but often overloads a transition in neutral professional writing.
Whereas the first model prioritises speed, the second prioritises transparency.
Whereas the first model prioritises speed, the second prioritises transparency.
This is a balanced comparison of two models, not acknowledgement of an obstacle.
Although the archive is incomplete, it contains the only surviving interviews.
Although the archive is incomplete, it contains the only surviving interviews.
Although already makes the concessive clause subordinate, so but is unnecessary before the main clause.
Register, punctuation and your own writing
Be that as it may and postposed notwithstanding are distinctly formal. Admittedly, Granted and nevertheless are common in argumentative and academic writing. That said is more flexible and sounds natural in a professional conversation, letter or less ceremonious analysis.
Punctuation depends on syntax, not just the word itself. First find the boundaries of the independent clauses, then identify the marker’s role, and only then choose a comma, semicolon or full stop.
In your own paragraph, concession should support the logic: name a real limitation without minimising it, and support the counterclaim with a reason or evidence. A variety of markers is useful only when each performs a distinct function.
The maintenance burden is, admittedly, significant. That said, the system has reduced processing errors.
The maintenance burden is, admittedly, significant. That said, the system has reduced processing errors.
Parenthetical admittedly is marked on both sides; That said opens a separate turn in the argument.
Reservations notwithstanding, the board endorsed the proposal.
Reservations notwithstanding, the board endorsed the proposal.
A concise postposed frame is appropriate in a formal summary of a decision.
Common mistakes
Incorrect:Although the pilot was small, but it produced reliable results.
Correct:Although the pilot was small, it produced reliable results.
Although already introduces a subordinate concessive clause; an extra but in this standard construction duplicates the link.
Incorrect:The evidence is limited, nevertheless, the conclusion is plausible.
Correct:The evidence is limited; nevertheless, the conclusion is plausible.
Two independent clauses cannot be joined only by commas around nevertheless; a semicolon or full stop is needed before the marker.
Incorrect:Notwithstanding of the delay, the team met the deadline.
Correct:Notwithstanding the delay, the team met the deadline.
Notwithstanding directly takes a noun phrase; do not add the preposition of after it.
Incorrect:Be that as may, the statutory deadline still applies.
Correct:Be that as it may, the statutory deadline still applies.
The fixed expression contains five words, Be that as it may; omitting it breaks its grammatical structure.
Incorrect:Granted that the sample is small, the pattern merit investigation.
Correct:Granted that the sample is small, the pattern merits investigation.
The pattern is singular, so the Present Simple needs merits. Granted that introduces a concessive clause separated by a comma.
Sources
- British Council LearnEnglish — Contrasting ideas (C1)
- Cambridge Dictionary — granted
- Cambridge Dictionary — admittedly
- Cambridge Dictionary — notwithstanding
- Cambridge Dictionary — be that as it may
- Cambridge Dictionary — nevertheless
- Oxford Advanced Learner’s Dictionary — say: that said / having said that
- MLA Style Center — Types of Sentences